Over the years, I've seen a steady stream of independent consultancies in the Infrastructure space get bought by bigger firms. Historically, many of the buyers were larger engineering groups. More recently, private capital has become a much bigger part of the picture, investing both directly and through PE-backed businesses. Some of these firms are Novaré clients, or organisations we have connections with at a senior level, and it's been interesting having a front-row seat to how several of those deals have played out.
Understanding why these deals happen is relatively simple - at least on paper. For the buyer, an established consultancy is a quick way to enter into a new market, sector or region. A bolt-on new service line theoretically creates immediate value, through acquiring clients and delivery teams that would take years to grow organically.
For the company being bought, it can mean financial backing to supercharge growth and access both to clients that might previously have been out of reach, and to corporate infrastructure that would take far longer to build alone.
But a deal making sense on paper is different to it being a good deal in practice. Some firms do manage to keep what made them good and gain the scale of a bigger business, but others change so much you'd struggle to recognise them.
So the question is: when a big organisation buys a successful specialist, how much of what made it successful actually survives?
What are the acquirers really buying?
Revenue, profit, client lists and headcount are the "on paper" value, and a multiple of EBITDA can capture much of this. But in my experience a lot of the value in a good consultancy firm is almost intangible - it's the culture, how those people work together, the reputation they've built, the way they go about doing their work. And often it's an entrepreneurial spirit that allows a smaller firm to punch above its weight against much bigger competitors.
Which in itself makes integration difficult. If you fold a small entrepreneurial business fully into the parent, you get various efficiencies, but I have seen time and again it can be easy to lose what it is that made the firm successful.
On the other hand, leaving it some independence seemingly increases the chance of keeping the culture, the relationships and the speed that made it worth buying - but potentially those efficiencies don't get fully realised. It's a trade-off, and hard to get the balance right.
How acquisitions differ
This isn't a new phenomenon - I'm old enough to remember Hornagold & Hills, a once prominent name before Mouchel Parkman bought it in 2006. Within about a year Stan Hornagold had left, along with a quarter of the firm's senior partners. Mouchel later passed through its lenders, Kier and WSP, and the Hornagold & Hills name disappeared somewhere along the way.
Twenty years on, I still see versions of the same story. I've spoken to senior people at one advisory firm who loved it as an independent boutique and are less enamoured now as part of a much larger group. A number of the senior leadership team have left, with others actively looking at exit routes. The new owner isn't a bad business by any stretch - it's just a completely different one. The people the buyer was paying for are the first out of the door.
But scale and autonomy don't have to be mutually exclusive. A client of mine had several suitors when an equity event was on the cards last year, and it was able to pick the owner that best matched how it works and where it wants to grow. Fit on culture, values and leadership mattered more than extracting the most financial value from the deal on day one. The management team remains in place, and they've got the backing of a bigger group, a strong degree of autonomy, and are excited about executing a growth plan which is underway.
The pattern
"Whether the people who built a firm keep a real stake and real control is arguably a better indicator of whether a deal will work than anything in the press release."
If there's a common thread, I think it's whether the people who built the firm stay invested in it. Davis Langdon's and EC Harris's partners sold outright - both names were gone within four years, and plenty of partners left to set up on their own. On the other hand, T&T's partners kept 40% when CBRE bought in, and four years later CBRE folded its own project management business into T&T.
What does this mean for the remaining independents?
The list of true independents - employee or founder-owned, without PE backing - in this space is far smaller than it used to be. Think of the names that were genuinely independent not that long ago. Some went to trade buyers: LogiKal to Assystem, Alinea to T&T, PA Consulting to Jacobs. Others took private capital directly: Gardiner & Theobald with Hennick, Mace Consult with Goldman Sachs, and even Grant Thornton UK, which sold a majority stake to Cinven in 2025. And a growing number went to buyers that are themselves PE-backed: Blackrock to Duff & Phelps, Aqua Consultants to Adler & Allan.
There are still some great independents out there, but as they grow they will likely become targets. The big firms have significant scale advantages and ambitious growth plans, but the senior leaders I speak to are quite open that growing from 1,000 to 2,000 people organically is much easier than going from 10,000 to 20,000 - hence their continued appetite to "buy rather than build."
Meanwhile, Private Equity money looks set to keep flowing. Infrastructure is seen as resilient to economic cycles, and ageing infrastructure is firmly on the list of megatrends that investors talk about. For a PE fund, consultancies are an attractive, capital-light way to get exposure to it.
Where it goes from here
What I'm not currently seeing is the next wave. After the Davis Langdon and EC Harris deals, a number of former partners went off to start their own firms. When CBRE bought into T&T in 2021, Rob Smith predicted the same would happen again. From what I'm seeing, it hasn't - at least not on anything like the same scale.
Today's deals are structured to keep people in, through retained equity, deferred payments and lock-ins. That's good for continuity, and it's probably part of why some of these deals are working. But it may also mean fewer of the breakaway firms that kept this market competitive.
If that's right, the next generation of independents is less likely to come from a wave of departures after one big deal, and more likely from individuals who decide for themselves that they want to build something of their own. They're the people I'll be watching for.